The short answer

Both work. The difference is who does the typing.

A spreadsheet gives you correct numbers as long as you update it after every sale and go back when eBay changes something. Software pulls those numbers from eBay for you. Which one fits depends on how many sales you have and how often you really sit down to update.

The software on this page is Autotabit, the eBay profit tracker I built for resellers. It connects to your eBay account and brings in your sales, eBay fees, ad fees and label costs. You add what you paid for each item, and it shows your real profit.

A spreadsheet is enough if

  • You have a handful of sales a month
  • You update it the same day, every sale
  • You rarely get returns or use Promoted Listings
  • You don't mind going back to fix old rows
  • You want it free and built exactly your way

Software starts to pay off when

  • Sales come in faster than you want to type them
  • You skip a few days, then face a pile of sales to catch up
  • You pay ad fees, buy eBay labels or get returns
  • You want to know which items and stores make you money
  • You've stopped trusting your spreadsheet's totals
Credit where it's due

What a spreadsheet does well

It's free

Excel, Google Sheets and Numbers all work, and a template costs nothing. Ours is free with no signup.

It's yours to change

Add any column, tab or formula you want. Nobody decides for you what gets tracked.

Your data stays with you

The file lives on your computer or in your own Google Drive. You don't connect any accounts.

Any marketplace

eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, Facebook, a yard sale. A spreadsheet doesn't care where the sale happened.

Tip if you stay with a spreadsheet: you don't have to copy fees one order at a time. eBay's transaction report is a CSV file you can open in Excel or Google Sheets, with the date, order number, fees and payout for each transaction. Download it for a date range from the Payments tab in Seller Hub, or drop it into the free Transaction Report Analyzer to see fees, ad fees, labels and refunds by month. Wondering whether Seller Hub alone is enough? Here's how close Seller Hub gets to your profit.

Where it fell apart for me

Five minutes a sale, and the numbers were still off

I tracked my eBay sales in a spreadsheet before Autotabit existed. Here's what that was really like.

The back and forth. Every new sale meant switching between the eBay order and the spreadsheet: copying, pasting, dragging, right-clicking, and typing in about 10 cells. By the time I went back and forth, it took me about five minutes to record one sale.

The catch-up weeks. On busy workdays I'd forget to update the sheet, and sometimes I didn't touch it for a week. Then I had 20 to 30 sales to catch up on and had to remember everything about each one. The numbers were always way off.

The changes I never saw. When a label charge changed after a sale, I wouldn't have known unless I happened to read an email from eBay. Returns were the same: I'd get one during a busy day and forget to go back and fix that sale.

The better way. I kept improving my spreadsheet with titles, tabs, formatting and colors, and somewhere in there I thought, there has to be a better way. That's how Autotabit started.

700+eBay orders on my account in 2026 so far
~60 hourswhat those orders would take at five minutes each
2.5 hoursa month at five minutes a sale, if you have 30 sales a month
The hard part

The numbers that change after you've typed them

Typing a sale in once is the easy part. These are the charges and credits that show up later, often on a different eBay screen, and a spreadsheet only knows about them if you go back.

Shipping label adjustments

If the carrier measures a package differently than you entered it, the difference is charged later. For USPS labels, eBay's shipping FAQ tells you to check the Shipping Cost Adjustments section of Manage Shipping Labels to see if you have any; for FedEx and UPS, the Shipping Labels view in Seller Hub. In 2026 so far, eBay added a label charge after the sale on 8 of my orders, one of them more than three months after it sold. More on label adjustments.

Returns and fee credits

A refund changes more than the sale price. eBay's fee credits page says credits depend on why the item came back, partial refunds get partial credits, and the per-order fee can take up to 10 days to show up. Then there's the return label. 27 of my orders in 2026 so far had a refund. eBay returns guide.

Promoted Listings ad fees

With Promoted Listings General, the ad fee is charged when the item sells, not when you list it, so it's one more number to copy from every order. 640 of my orders in 2026 so far had an ad fee. It can be credited back on some returns, per eBay's fee credits page. Are Promoted Listings worth it?

Cost per unit

Buy a lot of 10 for $30 and sell them one at a time, and each sale needs $3 of cost, not $30. A spreadsheet can do that, but you have to remember to split it every time.

Expenses that aren't one sale

Supplies, your eBay Store subscription, software and miles driven to sourcing. They don't belong to any one order, so they need their own tab and their own habit.

Items you haven't sold yet

A sales spreadsheet only gets a row when something sells. What's still listed, what it cost you and how long it's been sitting needs a second sheet you keep up by hand.

One real sale, before and after

A pair of Red Wing boots I sold in May 2026. Ten days after the sale, eBay charged $3.00 more for underpaid postage.

Sold price$59.95
Shipping the buyer paid$11.56
eBay fees−$9.95
Promoted Listings ad fee−$3.76
Shipping label−$9.56
What I paid for the boots−$9.70
Profit before the extra charge$38.54
Underpaid postage, charged 10 days later−$3.00
Real profit$35.54

A spreadsheet still says $38.54 unless you go back and change that row. In Autotabit the order shows $35.54, with the extra charge listed on it.

Beyond the totals

Questions a spreadsheet makes you build yourself

A spreadsheet can answer these if you add the right columns and build the pivot tables. In Autotabit they're reports you open, or a question you type into the eBay assistant.

Everything else Autotabit does →

Making the move

Switching from a spreadsheet

Your eBay history comes with you

Connect your eBay account and bring in up to 2 years of orders, with eBay's fees, ad fees and labels. What you paid for each item is the one thing you add yourself, many items at once with Bulk COGS.

When it's worth paying

At five minutes a sale, 30 sales a month is 2.5 hours of typing. Up to 30 listings, Autotabit is free. Past that, paid plans start at $9.95 a month. See pricing.

Your data isn't locked in

Reports export to CSV, Excel or PDF, and Export All Data downloads a full backup. If you cancel a paid plan, your account goes back to the free plan instead of closing.

What connecting eBay allows: Autotabit reads your sales and inventory, and only changes your listings when you start an action or turn on a rule. It can't make purchases, message buyers, move your payouts or see your payment info. Full details in Help.

Comparing tools? What to look for in eBay reseller software →

Either way

What to track, spreadsheet or software

Whatever you use, these are the numbers that decide your real profit on eBay.

Why your eBay profit is probably wrong →

Side by side

A spreadsheet vs Autotabit

Autotabit is the eBay profit tracker I built. Here's how it compares to keeping a spreadsheet, including what it doesn't do for you.

SpreadsheetAutotabit
Logging a saleType about 10 cells per orderPulled from your eBay account
eBay fees and ad feesCopy from each order, or from the transaction reporteBay's own numbers, filled in
Shipping labels bought on eBayCopy from each orderFilled in
Late label charges and returnsFind the old row and fix itPicked up automatically on your next sync, even months after the sale
What you paid for each itemYou type itYou type it too (in bulk, or when you log a sourcing trip)
Other marketplacesAnything you type ineBay syncs; Poshmark, Mercari, Facebook and others you log by hand
CrosslistingNoNo. It tags where else an item is listed and reminds you to delist when it sells
Questions about your businessBuild the formulas and pivot tables yourselfReports, or ask the eBay assistant in plain English
Changing how it worksAny column or formula you wantBuilt the way it is
Where your data livesYour own fileYour Autotabit account, connected to eBay; export anytime
CostFreeFree up to 30 listings, then from $9.95/month
Questions

Spreadsheet vs software questions

Is a spreadsheet good enough for eBay reselling?

Yes, if you update it after every sale and go back when eBay changes something, like a late label charge or a return. The math is the easy part. The hard part is keeping up with the typing.

What does eBay reseller software do that a spreadsheet doesn't?

Software like Autotabit reads your sales, fees, ad fees and labels from your eBay account, so you don't copy them by hand, and it picks up changes after the sale. You still enter what you paid for each item.

Can I use both?

Yes. Autotabit's reports export to CSV or Excel, so you can still open your numbers in a spreadsheet and add your own columns.

Is there a free option?

The free eBay profit spreadsheet needs no signup. Autotabit is free up to 30 listings with no credit card.

Done typing in fees?

Connect your eBay account once and every sale comes in with eBay's real fees, ad fees and label cost. Free up to 30 listings. No credit card required.

Start Free →

Not ready? Get the free spreadsheet