The short answer

Ask what it does with the numbers you can't see yourself

If you've decided a spreadsheet isn't enough, these are the seven questions I'd ask of any tool. They work on any eBay seller software, so no other tools are named here.

Under each question is how Autotabit answers it. Autotabit is the eBay profit tracker I built for resellers. At the end is a list of what it doesn't do.

Question 1

Does it use eBay's real fees, or estimates?

Before I built Autotabit, I only used Seller Hub to see my fees. Seller Hub is limited in what it tells you, and it doesn't make it straightforward. I just wanted to know exactly what I was making. It's nice to look at the end of one column and see the profit. I wrote up how close Seller Hub gets to your profit, with a real week and a real order.

That column is only worth looking at if the fees in it are real. When a tool estimates fees from a percentage, every number after it is only close, and you never quite trust the profit.

Ask: does it read the fee eBay charged on each order, along with the ad fee and the shipping label? Or does it work them out from a rate you set?

How Autotabit answers it: it reads each order's final value fee, per-order fee, international fee, Promoted Listings ad fee and shipping label cost from your eBay account. One thing to know: eBay can take 24 to 48 hours to finalize the fees on a new order, so a sale from this morning can still change. Autotabit picks up the final fees on a following sync.

Question 2

How does it handle refunds and returns?

This is the after-the-sale question I'd ask first. Every number is important, but returns are huge. eBay sellers hate them, and for every seller they matter more than a label adjustment.

A refund changes more than the sale price. eBay's fee credits page says the credits you get back depend on why the item was returned, and there may be a return label on top. The item also comes back to you, and what you paid for it has to go somewhere.

Ask: does a refund show up by itself? Do the fee credits and the return label show on the order? What happens to the item's cost when you list it again?

Under that sits a smaller question: does it catch a shipping label adjustment that eBay charges after the sale? More on label adjustments.

How Autotabit answers it: each sync checks for returns. The order shows the refund, any credits from eBay and a return label on its own line with the date, and the profit is worked out again. Returned orders have their own tab. When you relist an item that came back, its cost moves to the new listing: automatically if the new listing reuses a photo, otherwise after you confirm it's the same item. Late label charges are picked up on your next sync, even months after the sale. eBay returns guide.

Question 3

What do you still type yourself?

Cost of goods is the one thing no software can know. There are probably other little things, but that's the major one. Without what you paid, you can never know your true profit. It would always just be a guess.

To me, a proper tool is one where I only have to put my cost in and the numbers are accurate. That's the opposite of a spreadsheet, where you type or copy and paste everything.

Ask: what's left for me to enter? If the answer is "nothing", ask where the item cost comes from.

How Autotabit answers it: sales, fees, ad fees and labels come from eBay. You enter what you paid for each item, your expenses that aren't eBay charges (supplies, for example), and any sales you make on other marketplaces.

Question 4

How does it handle what you paid for your items?

Since cost is the number you enter yourself, how the tool takes it in matters a lot.

Here's my routine. Every sourcing day, I log the trip right in the parking lot, before I even pull out. Everything's fresh in my mind, and by the time I list the items, the trip is already in the app. At home I tag them to the trip as I list them, and my cost is in. Making it part of the routine solves the whole cost of goods question.

Ask: can it split a lot into a cost per unit? Can you set the cost on many items at once? Can you enter cost when you buy, instead of when the item sells?

How Autotabit answers it: cost is kept per unit, so an order for 3 units gets 3 times the item's cost. Bulk COGS sets the cost on many items at once. Log a sourcing trip and tag the items you bought, and the amount you spent is split across them, evenly or item by item. If you buy more of the same item at a new price, cost batches keep both prices. A sync never overwrites a cost you entered.

Question 5

Can you ask it questions?

Things pop into my mind all the time. What happened with this order? Did I ever get that label adjustment back? That box I thought was a bit too heavy, did they ever charge me for it? With no tools, who are you going to ask? You're just always going to wonder.

There are two kinds of questions. One is about a single order, like the ones above. The other is about the whole business: how am I doing this month compared to last month, or last year?

Ask: can I type a question in plain words and get an answer from my own numbers, or do I have to find the right report?

How Autotabit answers it: the eBay assistant answers questions about your own store, using the same math as the app's screens. It can give your sales and profit for any dates, list the charges on one order (the original label, then any return label or carrier adjustment) and list every order that got a label charge after the sale. It tells you which dates it used, and it only reads your numbers, never changes them. Two honest notes: its profit answers are only as good as the costs you've entered, and the free plan includes 25 questions about your numbers a month.

Question 6

Can you get your data out?

Your sales history is yours. Before you put a year or two of it into any tool, find out how you'd get it back out, and what happens to your account if you stop paying.

Ask: can I export my orders and reports to a file I can open in a spreadsheet? Is there a full backup? If I cancel, is my account closed?

How Autotabit answers it: reports export to CSV, Excel or PDF, and Export All Data in Settings downloads a full backup. The Tax Center has a "Download for my accountant" button that puts a year's report and spreadsheets in one file. If you cancel a paid plan, your account goes back to the free plan instead of closing.

Question 7

Is it worth paying for?

Three things tell me whether a tool is worth its price.

  1. The time it saves you. If the cost is justified by the time it saves you, that's the indicator. Recording one sale by hand took me about five minutes. At 30 sales a month that's 2.5 hours of typing, against $9.95 a month for Autotabit's first paid plan. So weigh it: two and a half hours a month typing into a spreadsheet, or two and a half hours sourcing, listing and shipping to make more.
  2. Having all of the information. What's it worth to you to have all of the information? Real fees, refunds, late charges and what each item cost you, in one place.
  3. Your profits. A tool is worth paying for as long as your profits can justify it. That's why Autotabit is free for new sellers with up to 30 active listings, and grows with them on their journey.

How Autotabit answers it: free up to 30 listings, with no credit card. Paid plans start at $9.95 a month for up to 200 listings. Every plan has the same features. Plans differ by how many listings you have, and paid plans get higher monthly limits on the AI tools. See pricing.

Not on anyone's list

The features you don't know to ask for

The seven questions above are all about your numbers. There's a second kind of feature that only matters in the moment: you're standing in a store wondering what something sells for, a friend hands you a box to sell for them, or a listing has been sitting for months. Autotabit has photo lookups, consignment, Auto Markdowns and End & Relist for those moments. They rarely make a checklist, but they're worth a look in any tool you try.

The tools nobody puts on their list →

Upfront

What Autotabit doesn't do

Ask any tool for this list too. Here's mine.

Autotabit doesn'tWhat that means for you
CrosslistIt doesn't post your listings to other sites. Most other resale sites don't offer API access, so a tool has to go in through back doors, and there's no way to reliably get all the information right. A missed update or a listing that doesn't end properly is how sellers get suspended or banned. Instead, Autotabit tags where else an item is listed and reminds you to delist it when it sells on eBay. How it helps prevent double sales.
Fully support variation listings yetSales from a listing with sizes or colors sync like any other sale, with their fees and profit. The tools that change a listing (End & Relist, Auto Markdowns, Auto Promote) skip variation listings for now.
Sync other marketplacesOnly eBay syncs. Sales on Poshmark, Mercari, Facebook and others are logged by hand.
File your taxes or give tax adviceThe Tax Center is a summary of your year to hand to your tax preparer. It's an estimate for reference only.
Work with every eBay siteIt works with seller accounts on eBay US, UK, Australia, Germany and Canada.
Questions

eBay reseller software questions

What should eBay reseller software do?

At a minimum, read the real fees, ad fees and label costs from your eBay account for every order, pick up refunds and late charges after the sale, make it easy to enter what you paid for each item, and let you export your data. Everything else is extra.

Does any software know what I paid for my items?

No. What you paid is the one number eBay doesn't have, so no software can pull it in. Look for a tool that makes entering it quick: per unit for lots, many items at once, or when you log a sourcing trip.

Is there free eBay reseller software?

Autotabit is free up to 30 listings with no credit card, with the same features as the paid plans. Paid plans start at $9.95 a month.

Ask these questions of Autotabit

Connect your eBay account and see your own sales with eBay's real fees, ad fees and label costs. Free up to 30 listings. No credit card required.

Start Free →

Still deciding? Spreadsheet vs reseller software